Home » Unlabelled » The Morning: “The Diplomat” vs. reality

May 14, 2023

By Lauren Jackson

Good morning. A popular show on Netflix is about the glamorous job of a U.S. ambassador. But is it true to reality?

Keri Russell as Kate Wyler in "The Diplomat."Alex Bailey/Netflix

Based on a true job

The allure of an ambassador's life is obvious: wielding government power and throwing parties for influential people in a far-flung location. "The Diplomat," which premiered last month on Netflix, highlights the glamour while omitting the drudgery of the job — the memos, press engagements and red tape.

In the show, Keri Russell plays a U.S. ambassador to Britain named Kate Wyler, who spends her days managing international crises with quippy retorts. She lives in a mansion, is photographed for Vogue and is married to a former ambassador, played by Rufus Sewell.

"The Diplomat" was Netflix's most popular show in recent weeks, and U.S. ambassadors around the world are watching. It transforms diplomatic doublespeak into a smooth script, but does it accurately reflect the job? New York Times bureau chiefs and correspondents around the world asked ambassadors how well the show represented their work.

"We're not as tough as the military, nor as cunningly cool as intelligence operatives," John Feeley, a former U.S. ambassador to Panama, told my colleague Damien Cave. "So to have Keri Russell and Rufus Sewell have sex and call it a diplomatic rapprochement? Well, heck. I'll take it. But it's a fantasy."

Here's what other ambassadors told my colleagues working in Mexico, Australia, China and elsewhere:

What the show gets wrong

Part of the fun of "The Diplomat," as with any workplace show, comes when it departs from reality. The ambassadors we spoke with were quick to point out discrepancies, both big (the lack of a Senate confirmation hearing) and small (Kate's use of a cellphone in the office).

"I have a different memory of the confirmation process," Rahm Emanuel, the U.S. ambassador to Japan, told my colleague Motoko Rich. "The show may get the diplomatic life right, but their grasp of American politics and the U.S. Senate? Not so right."

Here's what else they said the show got wrong:

The ambassador's use of military jets: "Yeah, right, I wish," said Richard Buangan, the U.S. ambassador to Mongolia. "Most ambassadors would fly commercial to our posts like everyone else. We must be excellent stewards of U.S. taxpayer money."

The rejoinders and banter: "Hyperbolic, unrealistic, amusing," said Carlos Pascual, a former U.S. ambassador to Mexico and Ukraine. "The speeches every diplomat wants to give his or her boss. Eloquence that saves the world. Not exactly the daily course of business."

A Vogue photo shoot: Multiple former ambassadors said the racks of outfits in the show were unrealistic. "Who's paying for all these clothes?" wondered Vicki Huddleston, a former U.S. ambassador to Mali and Madagascar. Huddleston did once pose for a photo shoot — for The Times. In the photograph that accompanies the article, Huddleston said, she wore her own dress.

And the lavish breakfasts in the ambassador's residence? "I don't eat breakfast," Emanuel said.

What the show gets right

Multiple ambassadors said the relationship between Kate and her No. 2 in the embassy, the deputy chief of mission, was accurate — along with the show's use of the acronym D.C.M.

Emanuel's office is next to that of his deputy chief, Raymond Greene, he said, so they pop in and out all day long. "Ray is often the first phone call or text at 6 a.m. and, somewhere around 9 p.m., also the last," Emanuel said. "And also 1,000 times between."

Here's what else the show gets right:

A sprawling staff managing everything: "You really don't have control of your life," Emanuel said. "There's parts of your life that gets cut up, chopped up, and everybody has a piece of it, and all of us are Type A personalities that like control."

The packed suitcase: "I laughed out loud during the scene where Ambassador Wyler freaked out after her household staff packed her suitcase, everything neat and tightly folded," Buangan said. "When my household staff packed my suitcase for my first trip up country, I freaked out, too. I'm not used to others touching my things."

The gender dynamics: "Women leaders who watch and learn before making changes, as opposed to the male 'marking their territory' approach," Roberta Jacobson, a former U.S. ambassador to Mexico, said. "She's smart, funny, pushes back on some of the nonsense and is a fast learner — traits essential for any ambassador and perhaps more so for a woman."

Some said they hoped the show would be good marketing for attracting recruits.

"'Top Gun' drove enlistments and interest in military aviation in the '80s," Feeley said. "I'm hopeful that 'The Diplomat' drives interest in foreign affairs and diplomacy despite its evident Hollywood veneer."

Keith Bradsher, Steven Erlanger, Natalie Kitroeff, David Pierson and Dionne Searcey contributed reporting.

For more

The U.S. Embassy in London made a video fact-checking the show (and making fun of a scene that involves an armpit check).
"My job is not nearly as sexy": Diplomats spoke to Politico about the show.
Several cast members of "The Diplomat" love the same coffee shop in Brooklyn. See how one actor spends his Sunday.

Continue reading the main story

NEWS

Turkey Elections

Today's election in Turkey is the toughest for President Recep Tayyip Erdogan in his 20 years in charge. Here's what to know.
A loss by Erdogan would be a relief for Western leaders and a worry for Russia, which could lose an economic and diplomatic partnership.

Homelessness

Abdul Curry cutting a friend's hair.Erin Schaff/The New York Times

"A daily game of Russian roulette": As a record number of people die on America's streets, Abdul Curry fights to stay alive in San Diego.

Jordan Neely, who was choked to death on a subway, was on a New York City list of homeless people most at risk.

FROM OPINION

"For all the pressure I have felt as a doctor or a writer, there is nothing that compares with the expectations placed on mothers," Daniela Lamas writes.

Here are columns by David French on Neely's subway killing and Maureen Dowd on CNN's Trump town hall.

The Sunday question: Should CNN have hosted Donald Trump?

The town hall normalized Trump as a candidate in the name of "ratings and money," Michael Fanone writes in Rolling Stone. But The Times's Frank Bruni writes that CNN was correct in identifying Trump as a potent political force, balancing him with a moderator quick to challenge his false claims.

The Morning highlights a small portion of the journalism that The New York Times offers. To access all of it, become a subscriber with this introductory offer.

MORNING READS

Kyle, Texas, is hosting a gathering of Kyles.Getty Images

Calling all Kyles: Kyle, Texas, needs 2,326 for a record attempt.

Vows: He swore off dating for a year, and then quickly found love.

Lives lived: Slava Zaitsev, a Soviet-era fashion designer, was once called the "Red Dior" by the Western press. His over-the-top theatrical creations and persona made him a go-to couturier at home. Zaitsev died at 85.

Continue reading the main story

ADVICE FOR LIFE

Parenting: The thrills and challenges of becoming a mother after 40.

A good gift: For Mother's Day, tell her she was right.

Mental health: Postpartum depression can be debilitating, but there are ways to ease the struggle.

From Wirecutter: The best beach umbrella doesn't look like an umbrella.

BOOKS

Kimberly Elliott

Unwelcome: In Emma Cline's latest, "The Guest," the heroine is a call girl on the run.

By the Book: The novelist Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah says academic works are labors of love, too.

Editors' picks: "Still Life With Bones," about an anthropologist's forensic exhumations, and eight other new books worth reading.

Times best sellers: Luke Russert's memoir, "Look for Me There," makes its way onto the hardcover nonfiction best-seller list.

THE SUNDAY TIMES MAGAZINE

From Kris Norelius

On the cover: Dementia changed her mother. When cognitive decline changes people, should we respect their new desires?

Remembering: A year after a white supremacist massacre in Buffalo, the victims' families live with grief: "There's no forgiveness for that."

Recommendation: Lurking on the internet.

The Ethicist: Can my new boyfriend stop my ex from visiting our dog?

Read the full issue.

THE WEEK AHEAD

What to Watch For

Former executives at Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank, which collapsed this year, will testify before a Senate committee on Tuesday.
Primary elections for governor in Kentucky and for mayor in Philadelphia are on Tuesday.
The Cannes Film Festival begins Tuesday.
A panel of federal appeals judges will hear arguments on Wednesday in a lawsuit seeking to overturn F.D.A. approval of an abortion pill.
The suspect in the stabbing death of the Cash App founder Bob Lee is scheduled to be arraigned on Thursday.
The W.N.B.A. season tips off Friday.

The Preakness, the second leg of horse racing's Triple Crown, is on Saturday.

What to Cook This Week

Ryan Liebe for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Maggie Ruggiero.

The recipes in Emily Weinstein's Five Weeknight Meals newsletter this week are quick to make but feel luxurious. Asparagus-feta pasta combines a yogurt-feta sauce with pasta and veggies and is adorned with mint. For olive oil baked salmon, the oven is at 350 degrees, which makes the fish extra silky.